
Pumpkin Pie marks the coming of Thanksgiving the same way Egg Nog signals Christmas, and when I saw the pies in the grocery store this year, I thought “$10 for a pie!” But when you buy the pumpkin ($3 at The Root Cellar), eggs, cream, flour, pecans and two hours of electricity to run the oven, $10 is CHEAP! But is it ever different making one from scratch…
My experience with pie making is very limited. I made an apple pie once, for my mother’s birthday, when she visited while I was living in Vancouver at the age of 19. And that’s it. So making this pie was an ambitious endeavour, but I am determined to continue Pumpkin Month, with a Get Fresh Local twist this year, so Pumpkin Pie was it. I found a very in depth recipe and article from the Joy of Cooking (even shares the history of Thanksgiving – worth a read) and decided to give it a go, with some modifications. The resultant recipe and experience are as follows…
Ingredients

Gobind Farms Pumpkin + Island Wheat Flour
PIE CRUST:
1 cup flour (*local: Island Wheat Flour c/o The Root Cellar)
1/2 tsp salt
1 tbsp sugar (I used golden sugar that I had on hand)
1/2 cup butter, soft (*local: Island Farms)
1/2 cup pecans, crushed
PIE FILLING:
1 Sugar Pie pumpkin, 2 cups cooked (*local: Gobind Farms c/o The Root Cellar)
3 large eggs
1/2 cup heavy whipping cream (*local: Island Farms)
1/2 cup sugar, brown or golden
1 tsp ground cinnamon
1/2 tsp ground ginger
Day One: Pumpkin Pie Prep
I know I won’t get a full two hours to make this pie, so I divide the tasks over two days. Monday night, while I make dinner – yay for multitasking! – I cook and blend the pumpkin.
1) Cut around the stem (same as for carving) and pull the top off.
2) Cut the pumpkin in half.
3) Scoop out the innards.
4) Oil the edges (where you cut) and place inside down on a baking sheet.
5) Bake in the oven for 60-75 minutes at 350F until soft.
6) Once cooled, scoop flesh from the shell and puree in a blender or food processor.
The next step suggests straining thru a cheesecloth lined strainer to minimize the liquid, but my strainer has tighter holes than cheesecloth, so I just strain it… but I have a little mishap… slooshing a quarter of my pumpkin mush into the sink! Oops, grr… (insert explicative here).
MEANWHILE the pumpkin is cooking, I make the pie dough!
1) Mix flour, salt and sugar in a large bowl.
2) Cut small strips or cubes of butter (1/2 cup’s worth) into the flour mixture.
3) With your finger tips, pinch and knead the butter into the flour (this step would usually be done with a food processor, but I am low tech).
4) Add a tbsp of cold water at a time as you mix the butter with flour until the dough holds together when pinched.
5) Turn the dough onto your work surface and work into a ball.
At this point the instructions tell me to flatten the dough into a disc and let cool in the fridge until use, but I should have skipped that step because it created a mess for me the next day: the dough was stuck (as in couldn’t lever it out with a flipper – or a crowbar for that matter) in the bowl! I solve that one quick by placing it in the warming oven for 5 minutes so the dough became pliable again. Because – duh, I didn’t realize this till now – butter becomes hard when it’s refrigerated! So, I highly recommend that you just skip right to the rolling and/or forming the crust stage! (See more on that below…)
Day Two: Pumpkin Pie Put-Together

Pumpkin Pie Filling
After the pumpkin is cooked and blended, I make the filling Tuesday lunchtime.
1) Whisk 3 eggs.
2) Whisk in 1/2 cup cream.
3) Whisk in spices (you’ll notice I skipped the All Spice)
4) Whisk in the pureed pumpkin.

Rolling the Dough
I fought with this dough… the second challenge comes with rolling… or more accurately… shortly after this photo, I can’t get the dough off the counter top! So I squish it all back into a ball, roll it together a little more, then flatten it into a disc and mush it by hand (and fist) into the pie pan to form the crust. Ah, finally a thing of beauty begins to emerge!

Forming the Crust + Filling the Pie
1) Once you form the pie crust, gently press in a layer of crushed pecans.
2) Fill with the pumpkin-egg-cream filling.
3) Carefully place the pie in the oven on a baking sheet to catch spills.
4) Bake for 55-70 minutes at 375F.
Keep an eye on it! It’s done when the crust browns lightly and most of the top looks set, but a little wet in the centre.
Ta Da! Finished Pumpkin Pie

Finished Pumpkin Pie
When the pie comes out of the oven, I oogle it… I can’t believe I did it. I just sit and stare at it (and grab my camera). I share the pie with my parents, who say, and I quote:
“Well, for the record…” (big pause, me nervously holding my breath) “… that is the best pie I’ve ever had.” – Mum (Wow, thanks Joy of Cooking!)
“There’s not too much spice, but it tastes real nice.” – Dad
And me: I can actually taste the pumpkin… and it’s delicious. And I think, this is what Pumpkin Pie (yes, capitalized) should taste like… FRESH. By the time I write this, the pie has long been enjoyably consumed. I think I’ll make another one and I hope my recipe makes enough sense that you do too. Happy Thanksgiving!
UPDATE Oct 12, 2010: Just brought to my attention that I had missed the 1/2 cup sugar in the pie filling when I had typed this up. Sorry!